POSTSCRIPT / September 18, 2022 / Sunday


Philippine STAR Columnist

Share on facebook
Share This
Share on twitter

Pope says it’s OK to arm Ukrainians

Remarks of Pope Francis that there is nothing morally wrong in supplying arms to Ukrainians to defend themselves against aggressors were certainly not made ex-cathedra, or “from the chair” of St. Peter, and so must have only persuasive effects on whoever disagrees.

Pope Francis discusses the moral issues over the war in Ukraine, which Russia invaded on Feb. 24.. Photo: Shutterstock

The Pontiff gave his opinion while seated, with a bad knee, on a jetplane flying the papal party from Kazakhstan back to Rome on Thursday. He was discussing with the press on board the war in Ukraine, which Russia invaded on Feb. 24.

The war hung in the background of the global congress of religious heads that the 85-year-old Pontiff attended Sept. 13-15 in Kazakhstan. Meanwhile, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights verified 5,827 civilian deaths in the war as of Sept. 11.

As Francis was talking with the press, meeting in Uzbekistan below them were the world’s top communist leaders – China’s President Xi Jinping and Russia’s President Vladimir Putin – vowing to firm up relations and advance their common interests.

During the 45-minute presscon of the Pope, a reporter asked if it was morally right for countries to send weapons to help Ukraine. That led to Francis’ discussing the moral implications of giving victims of aggression weapons for self-defense.

Catholics are taught in catechism that the goodness of a moral act is assessed based on three conditions: object (and its goodness), intention (or end as expressed by Saint Thomas Aquinas), and circumstances. For a moral act to be considered good, all three conditions must be met.

* * *

News reports that we’ve read about the in-flight discussion did not mention the United States sending weapons to Ukraine but we assumed that that was the context of the media questions and the Pope’s answers.

The US defense department said on Sept. 9 on its website: “Following Russia’s February 2022 invasion of Ukraine, the US embarked on a long-term commitment to provide Ukraine with the tools and equipment it needs to defend its sovereignty. Since that time, more than $14.5 billion in assistance has been committed to Ukraine.

“Some of the assistance provided has been new and purchased on contract from defense industry manufacturers as a part of the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative. But much of the equipment, some $12.5 billion worth, has been provided as part of presidential drawdown authority.

“That means things such as Javelin and Stinger missiles, HIMARS rocket launcher systems, and Switchblade unmanned aerial systems, for instance, have been pulled directly from existing US military inventory to be sent overseas.”

* * *

Francis, the only Jesuit to become Pope, said that arming victims of aggression can be morally acceptable under certain conditions. He explained the Roman Catholic Church’s “Just War” principles which allow the proportional use of weapons for self-defense against an aggressor.

“Self-defense is not only licit but also an expression of love for the homeland,” he said. “Someone who does not defend oneself, who does not defend something, does not love it. Those who defend (something) love it.”

When is it moral or immoral to supply weapons to another country? He explained: “It can be immoral if the intention is provoking more war, or to sell arms or dump arms that (a country) no longer needs. The motivation is what in large part qualifies the morality of this action.”

The Pope was asked whether Ukraine should negotiate with the invader and if Ukraine should draw a “red line” depending on Russian activities, after which it could refuse to negotiate.

“It is always difficult to understand dialogue with countries that have started a war… it is difficult but it should not be discarded,” he said.

“I would not exclude dialogue with any power that is at war, even if it is with the aggressor… Sometimes you have to carry out dialogue like this. It smells but it must be done,” he said.

The Pope, who was born in Argentina, used the Italian word “puzza” (smell or stink), equivalent to the English “holding your nose” to describe doing something one would prefer not to do.

“It (dialogue) is always a step forward, with an outstretched hand, always. Because otherwise, we close the only reasonable door to peace,” the Pope said.

“Sometimes it (the aggressor) does not accept dialogue. What a pity. But dialogue should always be carried out, or at least offered. And this does good to those who offer it,” he said.

* * *

In Samarkand, a city in Uzbekistan that was on the ancient Silk Road trade route linking China to the Mediterranean, the statement issued after the XI-Putin summit of Sept. 15 said in part:

“President Xi emphasized that China will work with Russia to extend strong mutual support on issues concerning each other’s core interests, and deepen practical cooperation in trade, agriculture, connectivity, and other areas. The two sides need to enhance coordination and cooperation under multilateral frameworks xxx to promote solidarity and mutual trust among the parties, expand cooperation, and safeguard the security interests of the region.

“xxx Both Russia and China stand for a more equitable and reasonable international order. The Russian side is firmly committed to the one-China principle and condemns the provocative moves by individual countries on issues concerning China’s core interests.

“Russia will work with China to promote continued, deeper cooperation among the (Shanghai Cooperation Organization) member states based on the principle of non-interference in each other’s internal affairs, so as to build an authoritative platform for upholding regional security and stability.

“President Xi appreciated Russia’s adherence to the one-China principle, stressing that Taiwan is part of China, the Chinese side firmly opposes the ‘Taiwan independence’ separatist forces and external interference, and no country is entitled to act as a judge on the Taiwan question.”

(First published in the Philippine STAR of September 18, 2022)

* * *

News RoundUp

Philippine STARMarcos tries Pinoy food truck fare in New York
Read More
Photos by Information and Communications Technology Assistant Secretary Anna Mae Yu Lamentillo and the office of Speaker Martin Romualdez showed Marcos, First Lady Liza Araneta-Marcos and some government officials ordering meals from food trucks in front of the Carlyle Hotel. (Sept. 25)
Philippine STARDOT to build tourism rest areas across Philippines
Read More
During a meeting with business leaders in New York where President Marcos held a working visit, Tourism Secretary Christina Garcia-Frasco declared the groundbreaking of the 10 tourist service areas is part of the agency’s “strategies for tourism development.” (Sept. 25)
Philippine STARWearing of PPEs no longer required for traveling OFWs
Read More
The Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (POEA) has issued an advisory against requirements of certain agencies for overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) to wear full personal protective equipment (PPE) while traveling to their country of destination. (Sept. 25)
Philippine STARDOJ to raise new issues in stronger case vs CPP-NPA
Read More
While the Department of Justice is dropping the option to file an appeal, the agency will raise new issues on its “stronger” proscription case against the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army after a Manila court junked its bid to declare the communist group as a terrorist...
Philippine STARMarcos calls for maximum restraint over Taiwan tensions, Ukraine conflict
Read More
Days after seeking support for the Philippines' bid for a non-permanent seat to the United Nations (UN) Security Council, President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. urged parties in the Taiwan Strait tensions and the Ukraine conflict to resolve their issues peacefully and expressed readiness to help push for a...
Philippine STARP1.9 billion refund in Russian helicopter deal? Government unsure
Read More
The Philippine government remains unsure if it can get a refund for some P1.9 billion in advance payment for the scrapped deal to procure 17 military choppers from Russia. This surfaced in the questioning of House Minority Leader Marcelino Libanan during the plenary deliberation of the...
Philippine STARBiden wants stronger ties with Philippines under Marcos after ‘rocky times’
Read More
At the sidelines of the UN General Assembly, Biden and Marcos met in person for the first time to discuss the alliance between their countries, the situation in the South China Sea, Russia’s war against Ukraine and its impact on energy and food prices, along with other matters. (Sept. 24)
Philippine STARAngeles clarifies claim Biden only spoke to Marcos at UNGA sidelines
Read More
Press Secretary Trixie Cruz-Angeles apologized Friday for wrongly claiming that President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. was the only leader who US President Joe Biden spoke to at the sidelines of the UN General Assembly in New York. (Sept. 24)
Philippine STARMarcos calls the US 'our partner, our ally and our friend'
Read More
Our partner, our ally and our friend. Those were the words used by President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. to describe the US before his American counterpart Joe Biden, who in turn, affirmed the "ironclad" ties between Manila and Washington during their first in-person meeting. (Sept. 24)
Philippine STARTaiwan to resume visa-free entry for Filipinos
Read More
Taiwan’s Bureau of Consular Affairs announced Thursday that nationals from the Philippines, along with nationals from 10 other countries, would again enjoy visa-free privileges as part of the island’s moves to reopen borders which it shuttered at the onset of the pandemic. (Sept. 24)



Share your thoughts.

Your email address will not be published.